When you’re first stepping into homeschooling, one of the biggest choices you’ll face is how to structure your homeschool legally and practically. Do you want to go fully independent, handling everything yourself, or would you feel more comfortable under the umbrella of a charter or private program?
The good news is: there isn’t one “right” answer. Both paths work beautifully for homeschool families; it just depends on your goals, comfort level, and needs. Let’s walk through what each option looks like day-to-day, the pros and cons, and how you can decide what fits your family best.
Independent Homeschooling: Total Freedom
Independent homeschooling means you are in charge of everything: curriculum, schedule, record-keeping, and reporting. For many families, this feels empowering because you’re not answering to anyone else.
What it looks like:
- You file any required paperwork with your state or school district.
- You choose your own curriculum or create your own lessons.
- You keep track of attendance and progress as your state requires.
- You decide your calendar, schedule, and pace.
Pros:
- Complete freedom in what and how you teach (faith-based or secular, structured or relaxed).
- Flexible scheduling, take vacations, school on weekends, or adjust as life changes.
- Privacy: no monthly meetings or check-ins.
Cons:
- Costs are on you. You’ll buy your own curriculum, supplies, and resources.
- Responsibility for records. If your state requires reports or assessments, it’s up to you.
- No built-in support. You’ll need to seek out co-ops, community groups, or mentors on your own.
Independent homeschooling is ideal if you love flexibility, want to design your own program, or prefer to avoid outside oversight.
Charter Homeschool Programs: Support and Resources
In some states, families can homeschool under a public charter school (sometimes called independent study programs or virtual academies). Your child is technically a public school student, but learning happens at home with you as the teacher.
What it looks like:
- You’re given a budget or free access to secular curriculum and materials.
- You meet with an assigned teacher (often monthly) who checks in on progress.
- You submit work samples, attendance, and sometimes standardized test results.
- You may be able to use funds for classes, extracurriculars, or enrichment activities.
Pros:
- Funding helps pay for curriculum, supplies, and even lessons like music or art.
- Guidance from a teacher if you want reassurance you’re “doing it right.”
- Community opportunities like field trips, group classes, or park days.
Cons:
- Restrictions: public money can’t be used for religious curriculum, and choices must usually come from approved vendors.
- Paperwork and oversight: learning plans, reports, and check-ins can feel like extra hoops.
- Less flexibility: charters may expect you to cover certain subjects or meet specific benchmarks.
Charters are a great fit if you value accountability, want financial help, and enjoy having a built-in support system.
Umbrella or Cover Schools: A Middle Ground
Umbrella schools (sometimes called cover schools or PSPs) are usually private schools that enroll homeschool students. On paper, your child is a private school student, but in practice you’re teaching at home.
What it looks like:
- You pay a tuition or fee for enrollment.
- The umbrella files paperwork, keeps transcripts, and sometimes issues diplomas.
- Requirements vary: some ask for attendance logs, grades, or portfolios; others are hands-off.
- Many offer optional extras like field trips, co-ops, or group activities.
Pros:
- Administrative help: they handle compliance and record-keeping.
- Flexibility: you can usually choose your own curriculum, including religious options.
- Community: some provide built-in events, classes, and support.
- Official records: helpful for high school and college admissions.
Cons:
- Costs vary: some are inexpensive, others are as costly as private school.
- Philosophy matters: you’ll need to choose an umbrella that aligns with your family’s values and style.
- Some oversight: you may need to turn in attendance or grades depending on the program.
Umbrella schools are a good choice for families who want independence but also appreciate having administrative support and a safety net.
So… Which Should You Choose?
Here are a few questions to ask yourself:
- Do I want full freedom in my homeschool, even if that means more responsibility? → Independent
- Do I want financial help, guidance, and accountability? → Charter
- Do I want someone else to handle the red tape, but still keep flexibility? → Umbrella
Remember, this doesn’t have to be a forever decision. Many families start with one option and switch later as their needs change.
Whether you go independent, join a charter, or enroll in an umbrella, you are still the parent-teacher directing your child’s education. Programs can offer resources and support, but the heart of homeschooling, the connection and learning at home, remains the same.
The best choice is the one that aligns with your values, comfort level, and goals. And the beauty of homeschooling is that if something doesn’t work, you can adjust.
Ready to Choose Your Homeschool Path?
Deciding between independent homeschooling, charter programs, or umbrella schools doesn’t have to feel overwhelming.
To make it easier, I’ve created two free tools just for you:
✅ Homeschool Options Comparison Chart – see Independent, Charter, and Umbrella schools side by side.
✅ Homeschool Decision Matrix – a simple worksheet to match your wants and worries with the best path for your family.
These guides will give you clarity and confidence as you decide how to start your homeschool journey.
Stick around for the rest of the Homeschool 101 series, where we’ll explore different homeschool styles, how to choose a curriculum, setting up your space, finding a routine, and much more.
You’ve got this! I’m here to help every step of the way.
- Jeni
___________________
**ALL THINGS HOMESCHOOL PRESCHOOL**
Check out my PRESCHOOL CURRICULUM! This is where you get all of my unit studies, activities, tips, and more!!
FREEBIE: Preschool Curriculum Map!
Check out my website for blogs and freebies!
All of the products on this page are products my kids and I use and love or products I personally recommend!
All of the opinions expressed here are my own. With that said, this page contains affiliate links that, at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission.
0 Comments